Back to Search
5537 Pelican Way, St Augustine, FL 32080
5537 Pelican Way, St Augustine, FL 32080
Sold for $1,075,000
5537 Pelican Way, St Augustine, FL 32080
Sold for $1,075,000
5537 Pelican Way, St Augustine, FL 32080
5537 Pelican Way, St Augustine, FL 32080
5537 Pelican Way, St Augustine, FL 32080
5537 Pelican Way, St Augustine, FL 32080

5537 Pelican Way St Augustine, FL 32080

$1,075,000

CLOSED
Beds
4
Baths
2
Sqft
1,940
Year
1983
Close Date
May 26, 2023
Property Type
Residential
Sub Type
Single Family Residence
Per Square Foot
$554
Date Listed
Feb 3, 2023

Description of 5537 Pelican Way, St Augustine, FL 32080

Listing details for 5537 Pelican Way, St Augustine, FL 32080 : Welcome to 5537 Pelican Way! Nicknamed ''The Black Pelican'', this newly-renovated home is steps to the beach and is a tailor-made short term rental investment or second home. Boasting 4 beds, 2 baths, a pool, and AirBnb-ready decor, this home is ready to start making money for you right away. Indoor and outdoor living spaces abound with huge views of the Atlantic Ocean from the front decks including the crow's nest that is one of the highest points in the Anastasia Hills neighborhood. Both the pool deck and second floor outdoor living area are fully screened with new screens making the perfect spots to relax and enjoy with friends and family. You can't miss the new exterior paint, Instagram-ready wallpaper, custom concrete countertops and vanities, new landscaping, and new flooring. Don't overlook the new HVAC components, garage door, interior paint, significant deck repairs, and countless other upgrades made in the last 6 months. This property will convey fully furnished and is ready to be your next money maker!
Listing Updated : 08-31-2026 at 12:25 PM EDT
IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by realMLS.
Listing Provided By

LUKE NEWCOMER, THE NEWCOMER GROUP

Properties displayed may be listed or sold by various participants in the MLS

Source

realMLS, MLS#: 1211148

Is this your home?

Claim it to unlock a private owner dashboard, track your equity, and get a free monthly value report.

Comments
Is this your home?

Claim it to unlock a private owner dashboard, track your equity, and get a free monthly value report.

Property History

DateEventPrice
5/26/2023
Sold
$1,075,000
$554/sqft
Source:realMLS #1211148
2/3/2023
Listed for sale
Source:realMLS #1211148
7/25/2022
Sold
$805,000 0%
$415/sqft
Source:realMLS #1171812
7/25/2022
Sold
$805,000
$415/sqft
Source:Stellar MLS #MFRFC278366
5/27/2022
Listed for sale
Source:realMLS #1171812
5/27/2022
Listed for sale
$899,000 +139.8%
$463/sqft
Source:Stellar MLS #MFRFC278366
9/26/2013
Sold
$374,900
$193/sqft
Source:realMLS #658475
3/21/2013
Listed for sale
Source:realMLS #658475

Location of 5537 Pelican Way, St Augustine, FL 32080

Google Map
Mortgage Calculator
Listing Price
Down Payment
Interest Rate

Schools Near 5537 Pelican Way, St Augustine, FL 32080

Is this your home?

Claim it to unlock a private owner dashboard, track your equity, and get a free monthly value report.

Comments

Homes Similar to 5537 Pelican Way, St Augustine, FL 32080

Sold Homes Similar to 5537 Pelican Way, St Augustine, FL 32080

Quick Flood Check

Wondering if this property sits in a flood zone? I can verify the address and tell you what it means in plain English.

Copy/paste to message me: “Can you run a flood check on this listing?”

HomeSt AugustineAnastasia Hills
Get Your Home’s Real Value — Verified by a Local Expert
Have a top local Realtor give you a FREE Comparative Market Analysis
Home904 on FacebookHome904 on Youtube
Company
Home904.com logo

United Real Estate Gallery – Park Ave
United Real Estate Gallery – Park Ave
1832 Park Avenue,
Orange Park, FL 32073
Home904 contact:
(904) 595-9249
First Coast Cities

Home904.com was built to make home searching in Jacksonville and across Northeast Florida clearer, calmer, and more accurate—pairing real-time MLS data with on-the-ground local context so decisions feel grounded, not rushed.

The site is run by Susie Takara, REALTOR®, a Northeast Florida real estate professional with United Real Estate Gallery known for steady communication, strong negotiation, and a relationships-first approach.

Whether you’re comparing communities in Jacksonville, Orange Park, Fleming Island, Middleburg, St. Johns, or Green Cove Springs, Home904 is designed to help you understand how a home and neighborhood will actually function day to day—at your pace, with guidance available when you want it. Home904.com is owned and operated by Susan Takara, LLC


© 2026 Northeast Florida Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved. The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) program of the Northeast Florida Multiple Listing Service, Inc. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than United Real Estate Gallery are marked with the listing broker’s name and detailed information about such listings includes the name of the listing brokers. Data provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed.