Back to Search
96233 Montego Bay, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034
96233 Montego Bay, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034
Sold for $755,000
96233 Montego Bay, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034
Sold for $755,000
96233 Montego Bay, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034
96233 Montego Bay, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034
96233 Montego Bay, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034
96233 Montego Bay, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034

96233 Montego Bay Fernandina Beach, FL 32034

$755,000

CLOSED
Beds
4
Baths
2
Sqft
1,984
Acres
0.22
Year
2004
Close Date
Aug 17, 2026
Property Type
Residential
Sub Type
Single Family Residence
Per Square Foot
$381
Date Listed
Apr 30, 2026

Description of 96233 Montego Bay, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034

Listing details for 96233 Montego Bay, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034 : Move-in ready POOL home on Amelia Island, perfectly positioned, just minutes by bike or golf cart to the beach and historic downtown Fernandina can be used as short-term rental! Built in 2004 and meticulously maintained, this home checks every box for island living at any stage of life, and with a relaxed HOA and county taxes, it is approved for short-term rentals, making it an exceptional investment opportunity as well. The River-to-Sea Trail is right nearby, making the beach instantly more accessible. The bright, open living area features cherry laminate floors and flows seamlessly to your private backyard oasis, complete with a saltwater pool, built-in bench, refreshment table, and soothing fountain. The fully screened enclosure and fully fenced yard make it ideal for kids, pets, or simply relaxing in total privacy. Major systems have been updated including a new roof (2021), newer HVAC and water heater (according to previous homeowner), updated irrigation, and gutters over the outdoor porches. The guest bath and most of kitchen have been renovated in the last 2 years. Hurricane shutters on the front provide added peace of mind, and a termite bond is in place. A water softener in the garage (never used by current owners) is ready for the next owner. Located in a quiet, established neighborhood that is central to everything the island offers, this home delivers the full Amelia Island lifestyle without compromise. You will not find a better deal for all this home has to offer on-island.
Listing Updated : 08-17-2026 at 3:30 PM EDT
IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by realMLS.
Listing Provided By

KELLI ALLEN, FERNANDINA BEACH REALTY

Properties displayed may be listed or sold by various participants in the MLS

Source

realMLS, MLS#: 2142706

What's this home worth?

National portals guess with an algorithm. We price it from actual closed sales on your street.

Your home value estimate
$627K – $874K
Exact number$2,845,000

Want an exact number? Use an Agent, not an algorithm.

Is this your home?

Claim it to unlock a private owner dashboard, track your equity, and get a free monthly value report.

Comments
What's this home worth?

National portals guess with an algorithm. We price it from actual closed sales on your street.

Your home value estimate
$627K – $874K
Exact number$2,845,000

Want an exact number? Use an Agent, not an algorithm.

Is this your home?

Claim it to unlock a private owner dashboard, track your equity, and get a free monthly value report.

Property History

DateEventPrice
8/17/2026
Sold
$755,000 -0.7%
$381/sqft
Source:realMLS #2142706
7/28/2026
Pending sale
$759,999 0%
$383/sqft
Source:realMLS #2142706
7/23/2026
Price Change
$759,999 -4.9%
$383/sqft
Source:realMLS #2142706
4/30/2026
Listed for sale
$799,000 +6.5%
$403/sqft
Source:realMLS #2142706
4/12/2024
Sold
$750,000
$378/sqft
Source:realMLS #2009664
2/5/2024
Listed for sale
—
Source:realMLS #2009664
7/30/2021
Sold
$430,500
$217/sqft
Source:realMLS #1117316
6/24/2021
Listed for sale
—
Source:realMLS #1117316

Location of 96233 Montego Bay, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034

Streetview of 96233 Montego Bay, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034

Mortgage Calculator
Listing Price
Down Payment
Interest Rate

Schools Near 96233 Montego Bay, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034

What's this home worth?

National portals guess with an algorithm. We price it from actual closed sales on your street.

Your home value estimate
$627K – $874K
Exact number$2,845,000

Want an exact number? Use an Agent, not an algorithm.

Is this your home?

Claim it to unlock a private owner dashboard, track your equity, and get a free monthly value report.

Comments

Homes Similar to 96233 Montego Bay, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034

Sold Homes Similar to 96233 Montego Bay, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034

Related Blogs
Quick Flood Check

Wondering if this property sits in a flood zone? I can verify the address and tell you what it means in plain English.

Copy/paste to message me: “Can you run a flood check on this listing?”

HomeFernandina BeachIsleworth
Get Your Home’s Real Value — Verified by a Local Expert
Have a top local Realtor give you a FREE Comparative Market Analysis
Home904 on FacebookHome904 on Youtube
Get in touch

Susie Takara, REALTOR®

(904) 595-9249

United Real Estate Gallery

1832 Park Avenue
Orange Park, FL 32073
Send us a message